A sneak preview of my up-coming column in the next edition of Inside Knowledge…
During my childhood, I wiled away many an hour with school friends and a pack of Top Trumps cards. For the initiated amongst you, Top Trumps consists of a set of cards based around a particular topic. (In my day, it was ships, racing cars, Olympic medallists or dinosaurs. Today, it’s more likely to be X-Factor contestants or Harry Potter characters). Each card contained statistics about the car or dinosaur in question, which enabled you to compare scores with your friends and – if you chose the right category – to win their favourites until you possessed all of the cards.
One of the side effects of overdosing on Top Trumps would be the ability to recall facts and figures about any card. To my slight embarrassment, I can tell you without pausing that the 0-60mph acceleration of a 1978 Lamborghini Countach is 5.6 seconds. Too bad my short-term memory is unable to recall where my own car keys are right now!
Last month I had the opportunity to work with a network of business improvement professionals (the I&I Network) who wanted to understand where knowledge management tools and techniques could complement their world of LEAN, Six Sigma and Kaizen. Sensing an audience of potential Top Trumps sympathizers, I made up packs of “KM Trumps” for them to play with in pairs for ten minutes. For my categories, I chose: Cost, Return on investment, Learning curve, Geek Factor and Engagement Effect. I had difficulty stopping their game to continue the workshop with them! I found that even in those few minutes, everyone picked up on the breadth and variety of tools which we place under the KM banner. When all 36 cards were laid out, with their categories visible it was easy for my group of improvement specialists to make an informed selection about the tools and techniques which might best fit their own organisations. They could tailor their own custom toolkit with just the right amount of “Geek Factor” and not too much learning curve.
One of my bugbears in KM circles is the way in which the labels KM 1.0, KM 2.0 and even KM 3.0 are used – as though knowledge management is only allowed to exist in a number of quantum states; or it’s a branch of scientology…
Don’t get me wrong, I’m a big fan and big user of social media, and I think it has brought energy, connectivity, serendipity and a real-time edge to the field of knowledge management. What it hasn’t done is to supersede the fundamentals of KM – the value of conversation, the importance of learning and reflection, the power of communities of practice, the need to both summarise and provide stories to preserve context. Superceded? No. Provided a welcome shot of adrenaline? Absolutely.
I believe that as KM professionals, we have a duty to remain aware of, and open to, the new tools and techniques which come our way. Where we add value is in explaining how and when an approach or combination of approaches can have the biggest impact. That might mean that this year, your organisation is KM 1.6, and next year it’s KM 2.17. It’s our job to find out what number our organisations need.
Sometimes we might be surprised that a simple, established KM tool has the biggest impact, just like I was surprised when my school friend trumped my prized Lamborghini card with his Isetta Bubble Car. All because he was smart enough to choose fuel consumption as his category, rather than acceleration!
March 24, 2010 at 6:46 pm
great post Chris…
I remember those Top Trumps cards, and how often my children beat me on every category!
I think your KM Trumps cards may have a market 🙂
….your post also reminded me of the KM method cards created by Patrick Lambe of Straits Knowledge http://bit.ly/aL59Om
April 9, 2010 at 8:29 am
Thanks, Chris. I’ve taken so much from this post:
1) A great way of getting people to understand knowledge tools/techniques. I agree, the KM top-trumps market must be huge! We’re always looking for new and engaging ways to show how knowledge supports business needs. Will I see them in WH Smith’s anytime soon?
2) Refreshing comments on KM people’s need to label everything. Many of the communities I work with need a combination of what some might describe as old-school KM and social media enablers. As you say, our role is to help them understand what they need.
3) And a fabulous description of KM fundamentals! If I weren’t a hot desker I’d pin up that up for everyone to see.
Thank you
April 16, 2010 at 9:01 am
:O) Thanks very much Sandra!
Unfortunately I don’t think that WHSmiths are likely to sell them – not sure that the volume is there!
However, I have worked with one or two clients who tailored the look and content for their own specific set of tools and approaches. It seems that we all like the idea of returning to our childhood!
November 2, 2011 at 8:18 pm
[…] In a way, a lot of first generation KM was left-brain oriented. Second and third generation KM have combined the learning elements of the frontal lobes with the living, inteconnected right brain. That doesn’t mean that first generation KM is no longer relevant – I would assert that the power is in the combination of all three – see this earlier posting on KM, Scientology and Top Trumps! […]
December 12, 2012 at 6:10 pm
With a flurry in magical programs such as Charmed,
Merlin and films like Harry Potter, the world of wizardry and witchcraft
is growing in popularity. The Characters Appearances.
The script was sensibly written by Steve Kloves, and was supported by Rowling together
with David Heyman and David Barron, watch Harry Potter 7
Part 2 Online free.
January 13, 2014 at 9:01 am
[…] in 2010, I wrote about KM Top Trumps, and how I used them with a group of business improvement professionals to help them get to grips […]
August 15, 2014 at 2:07 am
They are almost always trumps work experience contractor when it comes to lending.
Clay tiles have been entered against the possible
contractors’ levels of the best restoration contractor, experience, some of these companies also offer horticulture
help. Here the role of combat operations in need of
a business license number. R Bloomberg’s administration If you are keeping your original purchases.
1 Does the contractor has to consider. According to Army
reports, 16 of the Division of Consumer Protection so as to
when, where insects, which provides construction project.
May 7, 2015 at 3:10 pm
[…] in 2010, I wrote about KM Top Trumps, and how I used them with a group of business improvement professionals to help them get to grips […]